Sugar Tax Success for Mexico

c79429e0-937b-4828-bf4d-dfbe6e7f867aarticleimage.jpg

23 Feb 2017 --- More than three years after Mexico enforced a one peso tax on sugary sweetened drinks, there is evidence that fewer people are buying sodas with an overall decline of 7.6%. The latest data shows purchases of taxed beverages decreased 5.5% in 2014 and 9.7% in 2015, yielding an average reduction of 7.6% over the study period. 

Households at the lowest socioeconomic level had the largest decreases in purchases of taxed beverages in both years and meanwhile purchases of untaxed beverage increased 2.1% in the study period. 

Findings from Mexico may encourage other countries to use fiscal policies to reduce consumption of unhealthy beverages along with other interventions to reduce the burden of chronic disease, according to the authors of the study from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill’s Gillings School of Global Public Health and the Mexican Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública (National Institute of Public Health). 

As a result of government intervening more actively with promotional campaigns on sugar reduction and the introduction of so-called “sugar taxes” - the food industry is also responding with undertakings to reduce sugar content by reformulation of existing products and the launch of new lower sugar options.

The soft drinks category has led in terms of activity levels in reduced sugar products, with 18% of launches recorded by Innova Market Insights in the 12 months to the end of June 2016 marketed as low sugar, sugar free or no added sugar, rising to over 22% in North America. The highest levels of activity have been in juice/juice drinks and flavored bottled waters, where 21% of launches used one of these positionings globally.

Following the release of the results, the CSPI says Mexico is poised to reap “enormous benefits from soda taxes” in the form of reduced incidence of type 2 diabetes and other soda-related diseases.  

Legislators and health officials in Santa Fe, Seattle, and other American cities and states should carefully consider these early lessons out of Mexico and support soda taxes in their cities, according to the group. 

“If there were any lingering question about why the soda industry opposes taxes so vigorously, part of the answer lies in the findings released from researchers at the University of North Carolina’s Gillings School of Global Public Health: The taxes are driving down soda purchases, says CSPI executive director Michael F. Jacobson.

“In other words, the taxes are working as intended. Besides raising revenue, soda purchases declined more than 5 percent in the tax’s first year and another 4 percent in the tax’s second year.  And during the same period, sales of untaxed drinks like water went up slightly.”

Mexico was a pioneer in implementing the soda tax, initially enforcing regulations of one peso per liter on January 1, 2014. The country has very high obesity rates with more than 70% of the population overweight or obese. On top of that, around 70% of the added sugar in diet comes from sugar sweetened drinks and historically the population has been heavy consumers of soda, especially Coca-Cola. 

Health experts around the world have been watching the country closely over the years, monitoring the progress of the levy. The impact on public health remains to be seen. 

The study used store purchase data for 6,645 households from January 2012 to December 2015. Changes in purchases of taxed and untaxed beverages in the study period were estimated using two models, which compared 2014 and 2015 purchases with predicted (counterfactual) purchases based on trends in 2012–13.

BevSA Welcomes Further Consultation on Proposed Soft Drinks Tax

Elsewhere, the Beverage Association of South Africa (BevSA) have welcomed Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan’s announcement that there will be further consultations on the tax on sugar sweetened beverages before it is implemented.  

“Over the past few months we have continued to actively engage with government and other stakeholders to find a workable solution to the complex challenge of obesity in South Africa,” said BevSA executive director, Mapule Ncanywa. “We believe that through collaboration with all the relevant role players, we can find ways to create a win-win for all South Africans, contribute positively to health outcomes and avoid any job losses.” 

Following recent parliamentary hearings on the proposed tax, BevSA has been encouraged by discussions to identify the most effective solution to the obesity challenge and welcomed the opportunity for further consultation to underscore health outcomes.   

The industry has repeatedly called for a local dietary study to be conducted to determine the drivers of obesity as well as a wider socio-economic impact study to assess the cost-effectiveness of the tax.   

As an alternative to the tax, BevSA has proposed three distinct options to achieve results and these are:   
1.  Reformulating our products through lower to zero variants 
2. Committed to reducing three calories per day per person for 2016 and in this year five calories per person per day sugar reductions 
3. A consumer awareness drive

“We look forward to working with government to finding a solution to this serious and complex challenge that makes sense for all South Africans, while continuing to make an important economic contribution to the South African economy,” said Ncanywa.

by Gaynor Selby and Elizabeth Kenward

If you would like to contact the authors, email gaynor@cnsmedia.com or elizabeth@cnsmedia.com

To contact our editorial team please email us at editorial@cnsmedia.com

Related Articles

Food Ingredients News

Greencore sells US operations to Hearthside in US$1bn plus deal

15 Oct 2018 --- Greencore Group plc has agreed to the sale of its entire US business, Greencore US, to an affiliate of Hearthside Food Solutions LLC for US$1,075 million on a cash and debt-free basis. Greencore says that following the deal, it expects to have a leading position in its core UK market, greater financial and strategic flexibility and potential for dynamic capital management. Hearthside believes the transaction marks a significant step in the further growth and development of its network.

Food Ingredients News

Chr. Hansen acquires dairy ingredient supplier Hundsbichler, raises organic growth targets

15 Oct 2018 --- Chr. Hansen is further expanding its enzyme production and presence into the traditional segments of specialty cheeses, with the newly announced acquisition of the assets of Austrian-based ingredient supplier Österreichische Laberzeugung Hundsbichler GmbH. Hundsbichler products are widely recognized for high quality and the purchase will enable Chr. Hansen to offer cheesemakers a second-to-none product portfolio in the animal rennet space, according to the company. Separately, the company announced that it had achieved all the overall financial targets set at the beginning of the year and raised its ambitions 9-11 percent organic growth for next year.

Food Ingredients News

Start-up focus: US-based Variety Fun targets healthy and convenient snacks market, direct to your door

15 Oct 2018 --- Two entrepreneurs have turned their US$165,000 investment into a millennial-favorite snack subscription box, that is now projecting US$12 million dollars in sales for 2018 and over 500,000 boxes sold on Amazon. According to the company, Variety Fun’s subscription service delivers an assortment of snacks to US offices, improving workplace culture and boosting employee morale. Variety Fun is a snack subscription box that curates “hundreds of the best-tasting, classic and nutritional brands,” including Popcorners, Hippeas, and Popchips, for offices in the US. By partnering with over 500 snack brands, the company offers businesses the most affordable and convenient subscription snack service with the most extensive selection.

Food Ingredients News

Indian ventures: Alland & Robert and Sayaji collaborate on acacia gum production

12 Oct 2018 --- S.D.P.A., the holding company which owns French leader in natural gums Alland & Robert, is partnering with Indian-based company Sayaji Industries Limited (Sayaji) to form a joint venture. The main goal of this collaboration is to manufacture locally and supply spray dried acacia gum for the growing Indian market.

Food Ingredients News

Fattening up in weight management: Glanbia acquires SlimFast for US$350m

12 Oct 2018 --- Global nutrition group, Glanbia, is set to acquire SlimFast for US$350 million, from KSF Holdings LLP and HNS Intermediate Corporation who collectively own SlimFast and other brands. The company plans to operate SlimFast within its Performance Nutrition segment of the business which plays into global consumer trends focused on convenient formats and snacking, according to Glanbia. SlimFast is a well-established brand with high levels of awareness in the US, its largest market.

More Articles