Typical British Fish Supper Could Be Less Cod More Squid if UK Waters Continue to Warm

13 Dec 2016 --- Over the next ten years the profile of the typical British fish supper could become more like their Continental neighbors as climate change contributes to UK waters being heated to such an extent that more squid, anchovy and sardines, usually associated with the Mediterranean, could end up on the plate more than traditional cod.

Dr. John Pinnegar of Cefas (Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science), presented his findings at the British Ecological Society's annual meeting in Liverpool yesterday (Dec 12), which reveals that as UK waters warm due to climate change, cold water fish such as cod are gradually being replaced by warm water species like squid.

“Our models for 2025 and beyond suggest that seawater temperature may continue to rise in the future. As a result, UK waters will become more hospitable for some species and less suitable for others, with the overall result that most commercial species will move northwards,” he says.

Cefas has been monitoring North Sea fish populations for the past 114 years. Using detailed records of where fish are caught and of water temperature, it has been able to detect long-term changes in abundance and relate them to climate change and fishing intensity – as well as predict what the North Sea might look like in future. Data shows that squid numbers have increased dramatically over the past 35 years. In 1984, Cefas found squid at only 20 percent of its 76 survey stations in the North Sea, compared with 60 percent in 2014.

But while squid is on the rise, cod numbers have been slow to recover after overfishing. From a total stock biomass of 1.3 million tons in 1971, cod numbers fell to their lowest recorded level of 124,000 tons in 2004. Following strengthened management of cod fishing, biomass increased to 295,000 tons last year and, although this level is considered sustainable, scientists believe the slow recovery is because the warming waters of the North Sea in recent years have hit cod reproduction.

The results have important implications – for both UK fish suppers and the fishing industry. According to Dr. Pinnegar: “UK consumers enjoy eating quite a limited range of seafood, but in the long term we will need to adapt our diets. In 2025 and beyond, we may need to replace cod and other old favorites with warm-water species such as squid, mackerel, sardine and red mullet.”

Warming temperatures present both threats and opportunities to the fishing industry. For example, summer squid fisheries have expanded rapidly in the Moray Firth as efforts to reduce overfishing have prevented vessels from pursuing more traditional species such as haddock and cod.

“I would anticipate that currently small-scale fisheries targeting warm-water species such as squid, sardine and anchovy will continue to expand. They will probably represent a greater share of UK fisheries catches in 10 years’ time,” adds Pinnegar.

by Gaynor Selby