Bumble Bee Study Does Not Affect Neonicotinoid Conclusions, EFSA Says

5 June 2013 --- EFSA has identified several weaknesses in a study, published by the UK Food and Environment Research Agency (FERA), which suggested that neonicotinoid pesticides do not have a major effect on bumble bee colonies under field conditions.

Given these weaknesses, the Authority considers that the study does not affect the conclusions reached by EFSA regarding risks for bees related to the use of the neonicotinoid pesticides thiamethoxam, clothianidin and imidacloprid, published in January 2013.

The Authority made the following points regarding the relevance of the study, Effects of neonicotinoid seed treatments on bumble bee colonies under field conditions (Thompson et al.), to the risk assessments published by EFSA:
•EFSA’s assessments covered the authorised uses of a number of plant protection products containing thiamethoxam, clothianidin and imidacloprid across the European Union. The FERA study looked at only one crop – oilseed rape – and two plant protection products – one containing clothianidin, the other imidacloprid – authorised for use in the UK. Furthermore, the test sites and surrounding areas used in the FERA study reflect a small sample of agricultural conditions in the UK and cannot be considered representative of conditions in other parts of the EU.
•Two important routes of exposure – dust and guttation – were not addressed by the FERA study.
•In its assessments, EFSA reached conclusions mainly for honey bees, and identified a data gap for other pollinators. Field studies of bumble bees cannot be used to understand the risks to honey bees and other pollinators because of significant species differences.

EFSA’s experts highlighted a number of other deficiencies in the report. These include:
•Inconsistencies and contradictory statements regarding the objectives of the study.
•Absence of suitable control bee colonies. In particular, analysis of residues in pollen and nectar showed that the “control” site had been contaminated by thiamethoxam.
•Environmental conditions were varied across the three the test sites, which reduces the sensitivity of the study in detecting effects on colonies.

EFSA also raised concerns about how Thompson et al. elaborated and interpreted the study results to reach their conclusions.

Related Articles

From TWOFI

View From The Top: Antoine Baule, Chief Executive Officer, Lesaffre

Lesaffre is strengthening its presence in the nutritional ingredients fermentation and human health sector. It recently acquired Gnosis, an Italian company specialized in the development, production and sale of fermentation ingredients for the pharma, nutraceutical, cosmetic and veterinary industries.

From TWOFI

Allergen Control: Intolerant to Cleaning?

In facilities where both allergen containing and non-allergen containing products are manufactured on the same line, cleaning is a defining process in the changeover between recipes.

From TWOFI

View From The Top: Harold Schmitz, Chief Science Officer, Mars

Mars recently opened a Global Food Safety Center (GFSC) near Beijing, China, to serve as a pre-competitive research and training hub. The $15 million dollar center will house analytical chemistry and microbiology laboratories, interactive training labs and a conference auditorium.

From TWOFI

MetabolAid: Tackling Metabolic Syndrome

Metabolic syndrome is a dangerous condition in which high blood pressure, high cholesterol and obesity combine to increase greatly the risk of someone developing type 2 diabetes or cardiovascular disease. Metabolic syndrome is a global epidemic, but now there’s a powerful new natural formula to address it.

From TWOFI

Are Energy Drinks Becoming Natural?

Modern lifestyle is encompassing longer working hours, more complex family lives with the need for capturing both, career and caring for the family, reduced time for leisure, lack of sleep, and less time for preparing healthy nutrition. All of these factors are impacting the energy state in daily life at multiple levels. Energy drinks have the clear potential of gaining access to a broader consumer range with a need for sustainable and healthy energy.

More Articles